Lawmakers weigh whether to restrict local health directors’ authority over public health measures

1 month ago Nebraska Examiner

LINCOLN — COVID-19 placed an immense strain on hospitals and the medical field with thousands of cases and deaths in the nearly three years of the pandemic in Nebraska.

Public health directors as well as state and local governments issued directed health measures to mitigate the spread of the coronavirus, action that helped “save” local hospitals according to one registered nurse in Lincoln.

“When DHMs [directed health measures] were announced, there would be a collective sigh of relief amongst bedside clinicians, myself included,” nurse Julia Keown told the Health and Human Services Committee on Wednesday. “We would actually cheer because we knew it was going to work, and it did.”

Keown explained that the measures led to fewer patients dying from COVID-19 and fewer times health care professionals had to tell family over Zoom that their loved ones had died.

One legislative proposal seeks to change who can issue these measures, taking the authority away from public health directors and changing their roles to one of advisement.

Legislative Bill 421, proposed by State Sen. Kathleen Kauth of Omaha, would require county boards or city councils to vote to adopt directed health measures, alongside state officials’ approval.

“It maintains the importance of the education and experience brought by public health directors but redirects the responsibility of restricting liberties,” Kauth said. “This should also serve to redirect the ire of the public from the public health director to the elected officials where it belongs.”

Keown was one of five medical professionals who testified against the legislative proposal Wednesday. Two private citizens testified in support of the bill.

‘Maintain our rights’

Kauth said her bill is a direct response to actions taken during the pandemic that she said restricted individual freedoms. She said this included mask mandates and restrictions on public gatherings.

“It is critically important, especially in what may be an emergency, to maintain our rights,” Kauth said. “Elections have consequences, and the responsibility for decisions regarding citizen freedoms must live with those elected officials.”

The bill mirrors backlash in Lincoln and Omaha over health measures that led to a failed recall campaign against the mayor and city council members in Lincoln and lawsuits against the health director in Omaha for issuing a mask mandate without the city council’s approval.

Then-Attorney General Doug Peterson dropped his lawsuit after the Omaha City Council approved an ordinance allowing the council to veto public health measures.

Dr. James Lawler testifies

Dr. James Lawler, who is a professor in the division of infectious diseases at the University of Nebraska Medical Center, said the bill would make Nebraska less safe because it could delay health decisions.

In all of his experiences, Lawler said, critical and effective public health responses rely on speed, technical expertise and professional courage.

“LB 421 would undermine all of these in Nebraska,” Lawler said, adding that speed is the most important principle.

Day-to-day operations

The health departments in Douglas and Lancaster Counties issue about 120 work restrictions and isolation or quarantine orders every year, Lawler explained, excluding COVID-19. 

This includes action on diseases or pathogens such as hepatitis, salmonella, norovirus or tuberculosis, which all would need to be approved by elected officials.

“Most of the time, these orders are executed quietly. The emergency is contained and we never hear about it,” Lawler said. “But I, for one, am certainly glad these unsung heroes are working tirelessly behind the scenes every day.”

This means any directed health measure would require county or city as well as state approval.

Dr. Jim Nora, an infectious disease physician in Lincoln, testified against the bill and said medical professionals also want to uphold liberties and values. He said it should never be the intent of health policies to be arbitrary or discriminatory.

Jon Cannon, executive director of the Nebraska Association of County Officials, also testified in opposition. 

He said that gathering a quorum of city council members or county board members could be difficult, in addition to needing to abide by the open meetings act.

‘Arbitrary, wide-sweeping’ overreach David Splonskowski testifies

David Splonskowski of Omaha testified in support of Kauth’s bill because he said his family was hurt in the spring of 2020, mainly because of restrictions placed on church gatherings.

This placed an “undue burden” on his worship, he said, but these concerns fell on “deaf ears” when he contacted his county health director.

“It doesn’t necessarily prevent poor decisions being made,” Splonskowski said of the bill. “But at least it does allow residents to petition their local elected officials regarding the limitation of certain health directives.”

Stacey Skold of Malcolm, who has a Ph.D. in human sciences, said unelected officials ordered “arbitrary, wide-sweeping” mandates over the past three years that have eroded democracy.

Passing Kauth’s bill would close the loophole in medical directives, Skold said, arguing the bill needs additional language to prohibit injections as part of health measures. 

Ultimately, Skold said the Legislature should also develop a medical bill of rights.

‘Very scary time’

State Sen. Lynne Walz of Fremont, a committee member, expressed concern over how the bill would have affected her community during significant flooding in 2019.

Fremont became an island, Walz said, and if the health director’s actions involving  contaminated water quality had required additional approval, she questioned how that would have worked.

“It was a very, very scary time for the members of our community,” Walz said.

State Sen. Brian Hardin of Gering, committee vice chair, said Kauth’s bill would act as a check and balance on health directors. He pushed back against opponents’ testimony throughout the hearing. State Sen. Ben Hansen of Blair, committee chair, said the bill seemed reasonable due to the unprecedented action taken in response to COVID-19.

Dr. Echo Koehler, testifying in opposition for the Nebraska Nurses Association, said the bill would add “bureaucratic red tape” and undermine public health.

State Sen. Machaela Cavanaugh of Omaha, another committee member, repeatedly thanked medical professionals for their time in testifying and said openly she would not vote for the bill.

“You can thank me by not passing this bill,” Keown, the registered nurse, told Cavanaugh.

The committee took no immediate action on the legislation.

Continue reading...

Read On "Nebraska Examiner"
More News On "Nebraska Examiner"
28 days ago - Alameda County landlords owed thousands in rent, call for an end to eviction moratorium 28 days ago - Monday Feb. 27 COVID-19 update: 4 deaths in Douglas County 28 days ago - State basketball preview: 6A, 5A tournaments return to Weber State’s Dee Events Center this week 28 days ago - One Wealth Advisors LLC invests in Enovix Co. (NASDAQ:ENVX) 28 days ago - Uncommon length makes Pleasant Valley’s 2-3 a no-scoring zone 28 days ago - Study: Back-to-back hurricanes likely to come more often 28 days ago - What’s Happening Vegas? – March 2023 28 days ago - Osceola County community events calendar for 03/01/2023 28 days ago - North Adams, East Clinton, Unioto still alive 28 days ago - North Korea holds rare meeting on farming amid food shortage 28 days ago - 'Dilbert,' Scott Adams lose distributor over racist remarks 28 days ago - Soap or phone call? Colo. lawmakers want to make prison phone calls free 28 days ago - EXPLAINER: Windstorm was likely a derecho. What is that? 28 days ago - What's Happening in Las Vegas for this Year's March Madness 28 days ago - Outsmarting humans just one step for AI video game players 28 days ago - 'Cocaine Bear' gets high with $23.1M, 'Ant-Man' sinks fast 28 days ago - 'Everything Everywhere All at Once' dominates at SAG Awards 28 days ago - Digital Transformation: The Revolutionary Impact of Technology in Africa 28 days ago - ShotSpotter (NASDAQ:SSTI) Price Target Increased to $44.00 by Analysts at Lake Street Capital 28 days ago - Season 3 of Outer Banks disappoints critics; watch only if you were a die-hard fan of earlier seasons, they suggest 29 days ago - Board Game and Card Game Market Size in 2023 with [ STATISTICS FIGURES] Future Development Status and Forecast up to 2029 29 days ago - Tabletop Gaming Market Size in 2023 NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENT and Latest Innovation in Analytics Sector till 2029 29 days ago - Celona Offers Most Comprehensive Private 5G Solutions for U.S. and Foreign Markets 29 days ago - ShotSpotter, Inc. (NASDAQ:SSTI) to Post Q1 2023 Earnings of ($0.03) Per Share, Northland Capmk Forecasts 29 days ago - Asian shares track Wall Street decline on hot economic data 29 days ago - Final Nebraska high school swimming and diving season leaders 29 days ago - Girls BB: Saluting Section Champions 29 days ago - Tens of thousands protest Mexico electoral reforms 29 days ago - Third finals appearance the charm for Hortonville's Skebba; Stoffel makes history for Appleton North 29 days ago - Medical Blades Market Business Opportunities, Top Players and Forecast 2030 29 days ago - Central College Dutch Sports Update – 2/26/2023 29 days ago - Buhro takes individual crown as Oak Harbor earns sectional championship 1 month ago - Nebraska conservatives set sights on education takeover – Associated Press 1 month ago - Back-to-back: Minico successfully defends 4A state wrestling championship 1 month ago - Here are Saturday's high school sports results 1 month ago - Farewell, Fontana: NASCAR's last weekend at a racing gem 1 month ago - Kansas Democrats pick Repass as their new chair despite campaign baggage 1 month ago - Tesla’s Global Engineering HQ in Palo Alto — Opening Party Highlights (Pics, Videos, Quotes) 1 month ago - San Ann'as Pizza and Mexican celebrating 45th anniversary 1 month ago - L.A. on the Record: The Senate takes one more look at Garcetti 1 month ago - Dodge County real estate transfers 1 month ago - How UNL instructors are tackling the emergence of ChatGPT and other AI in higher education 1 month ago - Some Democratic-led states seek to bolster voter protections 1 month ago - Casey Vaughan: Only rain should go down a storm drain 1 month ago - Nebraska conservatives set sights on education takeover 1 month ago - West Michigan Conference basketball: Girls and boys roundup from Feb. 24, 2023 – CatchMark Sports 1 month ago - Jeff Yost: Look Upstream 1 month ago - Brokers Set Expectations for ShotSpotter, Inc.'s Q4 2023 Earnings (NASDAQ:SSTI) 1 month ago - Building affordable homes in Fremont 1 month ago - Local chef to open farm-to-table eatery in Fremont 1 month ago - Jeanna Wilcoxen Murder: Where Is Jeremiah Connelly Now? 1 month ago - More than 70 soldiers killed in Burkina Faso, extremists say 1 month ago - Clyde Council to consider citizens raising chickens in town 1 month ago - Wilhelm: More on Jacksons, Willow Hill and efforts to share insight into African American history 1 month ago - STATE HIGH SCHOOL WRESTLING TOURNAMENTS: Crowded at the top ... Trojans third, but well within striking distance in 5A tournament 1 month ago - Bulldog wrestlers have solid day at state 1 month ago - High school boys basketball: 6A/5A second round recap 1 month ago - Head-To-Head Analysis: Amprius Technologies (NYSE:AMPX) & Novanta (NASDAQ:NOVT) 1 month ago - Here are Friday's high school sports results 1 month ago - It’s Official: California Will Be Tesla’s Engineering & AI Headquarters
free geoip